Guelph’s pizza scene has evolved into something truly special, offering everything from traditional Italian pies to innovative creations that push culinary boundaries. Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita with perfectly charred crust or looking for a unique dining experience that combines live music with great food, this university city delivers. From downtown gems tucked into historic squares to neighborhood favorites that locals guard like secrets, Guelph’s pizzerias reflect the city’s blend of academic energy and small-town charm. We’ve tasted our way through the city to bring you the definitive guide to the best pizza experiences Guelph has to offer in 2025.
Quick Comparison
| Restaurant | Rating | Price | Best For | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 | Pizza Trokadero | 4.4 | $$ | Best Overall |
 | Buon Gusto | 4.1 | $$ | Italian Authentic |
 | Manhattans Pizza Bistro Music Club | 4.1 | $$ | Entertainment Dining |
 | Janet Lynn’s Bistro | 4.4 | $$$ | Special Occasions |
 | Pizza Prosciutto | 4.1 | $$ | Quick Takeout |
The Complete List
For a deeper dive, here are the full profiles, insider tips, and signature dishes for all 8 of Guelph’s best pizza restaurants, including some exceptional spots in nearby Kitchener, Cambridge, and Hamilton worth the short drive.
Pizza Trokadero
Pizza Trokadero has earned its reputation as Guelph’s pizza champion with dough that achieves the perfect balance of soft and crispy textures. Their commitment to fresh toppings and quality cheese creates pizzas that locals consistently rave about, with many declaring it simply the best pizza in the city.
Buon Gusto
Located in the heart of St. George’s Square, Buon Gusto brings authentic Italian flavors to downtown Guelph. While known for their handmade pasta, their pizza offerings maintain the same commitment to traditional Italian preparation methods and quality ingredients.
Manhattans Pizza Bistro Music Club
Manhattans offers a unique dining experience that combines quality pizza with live entertainment in an eclectic, classy atmosphere. The small-town friendly staff and vibrant music scene make this more than just a meal – it’s an experience that captures Guelph’s community spirit.
🚗 Worth the Drive
These top-rated spots are just a short drive from Guelph and well worth the trip.
Janet Lynn’s Bistro
While primarily known for upscale dining featuring steak and seafood, Janet Lynn’s Bistro elevates pizza to fine dining status. Their attention to detail and premium ingredients make this a special occasion destination for pizza lovers seeking a more refined experience.
Pizza Prosciutto
Pizza Prosciutto excels at delivering perfectly balanced flavors with just the right amount of sauce and meat. Their panzerotti have become legendary among locals, offering a unique twist on traditional pizza that showcases their attention to proportion and quality.
Andy’s Pizza
Andy’s Pizza has perfected the art of crispy crust pizza with fresh toppings including real bacon slices and a sauce that keeps customers coming back. Their commitment to quality ingredients and consistent preparation has earned them a loyal following in Cambridge.
Cowabunga
Cowabunga has achieved cult status among pizza enthusiasts with slices that completely redefine expectations. Their pizza is so exceptional that customers describe it as life-changing, with each bite delivering flavors that surpass every other pizza experience.
Bronzie’s Place
Bronzie’s Place combines exceptional pizza with legendary meatballs that redefine Italian-American comfort food. This Hamilton gem offers a complete Italian dining experience where pizza shares the spotlight with other outstanding dishes in a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
Frequently Asked Questions
Based on our research, Pizza Trokadero takes the top spot with its perfect balance of soft yet crispy dough, fresh toppings, and quality cheese. Their Margherita and Alfredo White pizzas consistently earn rave reviews from locals who consider it the best pizza in the city.
For budget-friendly options, Cowabunga offers exceptional value at just $ price point, though it’s takeout-only. Pizza Prosciutto and Andy’s Pizza also provide excellent quality at reasonable $$ prices, with Pizza Prosciutto being particularly great for quick takeout orders.
For celebrations, Janet Lynn’s Bistro elevates pizza to fine dining status with premium ingredients and an upscale atmosphere. Buon Gusto in downtown’s St. George’s Square offers authentic Italian ambiance perfect for date nights, while Manhattans combines great pizza with live entertainment for group celebrations.
Final Thoughts
Guelph’s pizza scene offers something for every craving and occasion. Whether you’re seeking the perfect slice at Pizza Trokadero, an authentic Italian experience at Buon Gusto, or entertainment with your meal at Manhattans, these eight spots represent the best pizza experiences the region has to offer in 2025.